Digital Marketing ROI with Len Ward

by | Podcast, Top

Podcasts

 

A former Wall Street banker on what return on investment really means — and why most business owners have no earthly idea whether their marketing is working.

Digital marketing and ROI go together like peanut butter and jelly. If you let it.

Most people picture digital marketing as a kind of conjuring trick: slap up a template you found online for free, and presto, the phone starts ringing and the sales chart goes rocketing toward Mars. It’s a lovely fantasy, and it’s nonsense. Ask a real business owner what their digital marketing return on investment actually is and you’ll usually get a blank stare, or a number plucked from something they half-heard in a coffee shop. Return on investment is nothing more mysterious than what you get back — in money, in time, in leads, in reach — for what you put in. And here’s the quiet trouble at the heart of it: without some honest read on that return, an owner has no way of knowing whether any of it is working. ROI is the compass. Sail without it and you’re just drifting and hoping.

So I wanted to spend an episode on the two halves of the problem — what to measure, and how to talk about it plainly — and for the second half I brought in someone who has lived it from both sides of the ledger. But first, the groundwork.

What’s actually worth measuring

When we talk about measuring digital marketing ROI, a handful of things matter more than the rest, and they stack one atop the other. It begins with traffic — who is visiting your site, when, and from what sources — because everything downstream depends on someone showing up at all. From there you narrow the lens to your pages and posts: which ones draw the most eyes, at what hours, from which corners of the web and which search terms, so you learn what your audience actually wants rather than what you assumed they did. Then comes the harder question of behavior, of what visitors do once they’re through the door — do they linger and read, or bounce away in a few restless seconds; do they subscribe, buy, book a consultation, fill out the contact form. Beneath all of that sits the money: the sales you can trace directly back to a specific page or post, which is where measurement stops being academic and starts paying rent. And quietly valuable alongside the sales are your newsletter subscribers, that captive, willing audience you can return to again and again with an offer, a discount, a new release — an asset worth far more than its modest size suggests.

What strong ROI actually looks like

Healthy ROI tends to announce itself in four ways. The first and most obvious is increased sales — a professional presence, a site that ranks, working e-commerce — and it’s worth remembering how easily that vanishes for the owners Mark Cuban once called “wantrepreneurs,” the ones who let a hosting plan lapse and watch the whole edifice evaporate overnight. The second is reduced overhead, the unglamorous magic of automation — automated receipts, online payments, digital downloads — that hands you back the hours you’d otherwise spend tinkering, hours you can pour into actually running or growing the thing. The third is steadier lead conversion, the simple pleasure of more qualified prospects arriving on a regular rhythm rather than in famine-and-feast lurches. And the fourth, the one most owners never even glimpse, is expansion into entirely new markets — the ability, say, to bid on government contracts, most of which require a modern, mobile-friendly, findable site that the average business simply doesn’t have, which leaves the field wide open for the few who do.

That’s the theory, and theory is cheap. For the lived practice of it, I called in Len Ward.

From the trading floor down the rabbit hole

Len arrived at digital marketing by a road almost no one else has walked. He started as a stockbroker at Morgan Stanley straight out of college, then moved to the investment-banking side at Credit Suisse First Boston, now Credit Suisse, right in the thick of the dot-com bubble — watching Google and Amazon go public, watching a crowded field of some thirty-five search engines while Yahoo still wore the crown, watching, as he put it, a whole world about to change in the way people now talk about crypto. When a merger and some trouble at home gave him the chance, he parachuted out and joined an e-commerce startup selling high-end event tickets — Broadway seats, the Gershwin Theater — to the very investment-banker types he’d just left behind. They hired an ad agency to handle SEO, the agency underdelivered, and rather than simply firing them Len went down the rabbit hole himself, teaching himself the craft and even going back to community college to learn enough code to implement what he was reading about. He optimized the site, picked up backlinking and content, and the traffic came. Then 2008 arrived, the housing market collapsed, and the people who’d been buying thousand-dollar Broadway tickets were suddenly losing their homes. The luxury-ticket trade cratered — but by then a few people had asked Len to fix their own websites, the freelance work snowballed, and almost before he’d noticed it he walked out of his home office one morning and into a real one, with twenty employees staring back at him. He likes to say he grew up with digital, watched it born with Google and grew up alongside it, and at nearly fifty he’s one of the few old heads who’ve seen the whole arc.

Research is not results

I asked Len how he’d known, back in those early days, that the agency wasn’t earning its keep — because most owners today are in the same boat and don’t know it. His answer was sharp: the agency kept delivering research and calling it progress. Call after call of keyword research, reports a mile long, and nothing ever implemented. He wasn’t even looking for results yet; he just needed the plan executed, because he understood that organic growth takes time to ripen. A plan that never leaves the research phase isn’t a slow plan, it’s no plan. He also pointed out how much the ground has shifted: back then you ranked for an exact keyword — “Broadway tickets Gershwin Theater” — and lived or died by literal ranking reports, which is precisely why those reports went the way of the dinosaurs once Google’s smarter, intent-reading search arrived and a single phrase could splinter into thousands of variations.

The mad rush to the digital gates

Len gets genuinely worked up about the typical client journey, and he’s earned the right to. Too many owners insist on doing everything themselves with a template builder, or let a Facebook page stand in for an actual website, or run a site with no SEO or, worse, confidently wrong SEO — and meanwhile they’re not touching pay-per-click, e-commerce, or content at all. What galls him is the contradiction: the same owners who tell you they’re struggling have no e-commerce and no real search presence, the very things they needed five years ago and need doubly now. Part of the cause, he argues, is a failure to grasp the business model underneath the platforms — Google and Facebook are built, top to bottom, to be paid, so a free Facebook post is never the whole answer, and even the “free” channels like SEO still cost the price of someone competent to do them. And underneath all of it lingers a stubborn suspicion that the internet is a passing fad, a bit of rock and roll that surely can’t last — a mindset the pandemic should have buried, since COVID forced everyone digital at once, yet what followed was a frantic, expensive scramble to the gates done mostly the wrong way.

I told Len about a lawyer I’d once spoken with who captured the whole disconnect in a single phone call. She practiced in two areas of law, she was getting zero calls and zero emails, and she couldn’t understand why — all while spending two or three thousand dollars a month on Google Ads, sitting on a template-builder website, with no SEO whatsoever and no idea what SEO even was. Money pouring out, nothing coming back, and no instrument on the dashboard to tell her why. That gap — between what she was spending and what she understood — is the exact territory Len has built a career on closing.

Forget the tactics — find the funnel

Len’s great trick is refusing to drag the business owner down into the muck of SEO and pay-per-click, because that muck is where most agencies lose them. He starts somewhere simpler and more financial: a funnel. Awareness, consideration, purchase — three honest stages — and a single question, where is your problem? An owner who says nobody’s calling has just told you the trouble lives at the top or the middle of the funnel, which points toward awareness and lead generation rather than, say, more blog posts. From there the spending question answers itself, and the old chestnut about devoting ten percent of gross revenue to marketing turns out to be hopelessly antiquated. Your number isn’t a flat percentage; it’s dictated by where your funnel leaks and what the current bidding environment on Google and Facebook actually costs. Sometimes the math comes back ugly — the fix might run thirty percent of revenue — and the honest counsel is no longer “let’s out-optimize it,” because you can’t out-optimize these platforms anymore. Sometimes the real answer is to cut overhead, sell the vans, shrink the office, because that is simply what the channels now demand.

He’s measured, too, about studying the competition. By all means know what your rivals are doing, he says, but never forget their funnel isn’t yours. The pest-control company down the road that seems to be outspending you into oblivion may simply need a flood of leads to bankroll an owner’s lavish lifestyle, while you live comfortably beneath your means and need nothing of the sort. Ask why they market the way they do before you imitate it, and accept that a bigger competitor eating your lunch may be running on infrastructure and scale a smaller shop just can’t match.

You can’t know your ROI without knowing your CAC

The single biggest reason owners guess at their return, or never learn it at all, is that they don’t understand their customer acquisition cost — and without that number, Len says flatly, ROI is unknowable. CAC is the whole, honest tally of everything you spend to win a customer: the sales effort and the marketing both, the CRM and the martech, the website design, the brochures, the networking, the sponsorships, the Google and Facebook spend — and, the line everyone forgets, especially attorneys, your own time. Add the entire pile up, divide by the number of customers it actually produced, and only then can a formula tell you whether the effort turned a profit. The other half of the failure is that owners rarely set a firm goal number before they start, so when a campaign is declared to be “failing” there’s no original target to measure it against. E-commerce and subscription companies know their CAC cold; almost everyone else is flying blind.

Conversions happen in an ecosystem

This was Len’s favorite refrain, and the most useful idea in the hour. A conversion is almost never the work of one channel; it happens inside an ecosystem. Picture the buyer headed toward a fifty-thousand-dollar pest-control job: he plays a round of golf beside a banner with the company’s name, half-remembers it, Googles it later, notices they sponsored that very tournament, gets quietly retargeted on Facebook, then passes one of their wrapped trucks on his morning commute and finally pulls over to find them on the map and book an estimate. No single touch closed that deal; the whole web of them did. Which is why Len begs people not to obsess over return on ad spend as a lone metric — it’s a misleading number, crediting one channel for what the entire ecosystem earned. The average person needs ten to fifteen touches before deciding, barring an emergency, so the real work is allocating your customer acquisition cost sensibly across that journey and weighting each stage properly. Get the mix right and the return follows; when it doesn’t, you go back to the CAC and ask whether you need more trucks, more Google, or another sponsorship — which is exactly where a good consultant earns their fee.

Why the marketer always gets blamed

Len built his ROI practice out of sheer exasperation, and the story behind it is the moral of the whole conversation. Again and again he’d watched marketers — freelancers and agency owners, most of them genuinely capable — wheeled into a boardroom and blamed for a missing return that was never theirs to deliver. An owner would clear six million dollars, invest two hundred thousand in marketing, quietly credit the in-house rainmaker for all the real business, and then turn around and demand to know why the agency hadn’t produced another two million. The arithmetic was absurd, but the owners didn’t understand the finances well enough to see it, so the marketer became the scapegoat. Having spent years absorbing high-level finance by osmosis in rooms most people never sit in, Len decided to solve it. His firm runs an ROI audit through a simple questionnaire and a dashboard — a proprietary method riding on an off-the-shelf platform — that lays bare the client’s current return, shows where the money is being allocated, maps the sales funnels, and then, once goals are set, reallocates the customer acquisition cost and hands the marketing team a real budget. After that the dashboard simply runs, and the owner watches their return on investment in something close to real time. It’s clever enough that I told him it ought to be a WordPress plugin — and only half in jest.

For the freelancers: kill scope creep early

Since so much of my own road has run through freelancing, I asked Len for his hardest-won advice, and it came down to a single discipline: address scope creep the moment it appears. Let it slide and clients will keep drifting back for “one small change,” each one free in their minds, until the unpaid work quietly bleeds you dry — and you can be certain no company doing over a million dollars a year will ever work for free, so neither should you. The defense is a clean, plain document that says, in so many words, two revisions are included and anything past that costs more. Better still, make the client do the heavy lifting up front: don’t start a website until their content is actually ready, because once it’s in hand you finally know what they want. And the truth that owners most need to hear is that changing a single element on a finished site is like asking to move a house’s front door around to the side — it isn’t a quick swap, it cascades through the branding, the colors, the fonts, the backlinks, and the SEO, and it is never as cheap or as fast as it looks.

Len’s parting mantras

He left listeners with two lines worth taping above a desk. The first: conversions happen in an ecosystem — don’t ever forget it. The second: do not try to out-optimize a bad spend, because no amount of clever tinkering will rescue money poured into the wrong place, a fact the relentlessly climbing share prices of Google and Facebook ought to make plain. And threaded through both is the through-line of the whole conversation — that there is no honest return on investment without first knowing the cost of acquiring a customer. Keep those three truths in mind walking into any digital campaign, and the road gets considerably smoother.

About Len

Len Ward is the owner of Commexis, a marketing consulting firm specializing in the financial auditing, investment allocation, and reporting of digital marketing campaigns. He began his career on Wall Street — as a stockbroker at Morgan Stanley and then in investment banking at Credit Suisse First Boston — before leaving finance in the mid-2000s for an e-commerce venture, teaching himself SEO and web development along the way and building an agency, RankMeSEO, out of his early freelance work. Today, through Commexis, he helps business owners see deliberate, specific investment metrics for their marketing efforts, and his firm has worked with brands including the University of Pennsylvania, Johnson & Johnson, American Water, ESF Camps, Exceptional Foods, Analysis Prime, and Thyroid Virtual Clinic.

Watch & Listen

You can take in the full conversation in whichever form you prefer. Watch the video version on YouTube or BitChute, or listen to the audio on Spotify or iHeartRadio, all linked below.

Learn More About Len

You can find Len and his team online at the link below.